Joshua Weissman Recipes

The McDonald's Egg McMuffin But Better

20 November 2026 · 12:21 watch

Advertisement

What makes the Egg McMuffin work and how to improve it at home: butter instead of margarine, round versus folded egg, and the mason-jar-lid trick for a tender egg.

Key takeaways

  • McDonald's switched from margarine to butter on the muffin and griddle in 2015.
  • The round egg is cooked in a ring so it fits the muffin.
  • The folded egg is a supplier-made, frozen product with a fluffier, omelette-like texture.
  • An inverted mason jar lid in a skillet shapes a tender, evenly white egg in about two minutes.

The Egg McMuffin is built from very little — an egg, a slice of Canadian bacon and American cheese on a toasted English muffin — so each part carries weight. Its defining detail is the egg, cooked in a ring so it sits flush with the muffin, a signature of the sandwich since it launched as a portable take on eggs Benedict. It was introduced in 1972 and rolled out nationwide in 1976.

Butter on the muffin and the griddle

For most of its life the muffin was brushed with margarine. In 2015 McDonald's switched to butter, using the same fat on the griddleGriddleA flat heated cooking surface used for foods such as pancakes, eggs and burgers. for eggs and other breakfast items — a significant cost decision given that butter is the more expensive fat. The sandwich still uses real butter, and the freshly cracked egg is cooked in liquid butter on the grillGrillTo cook using direct radiant heat.. Butter brings a denser, richer flavour, though quality varies widely between brands, so the butter you choose shows in the finished muffin.

Round egg or folded egg?

The round egg is a deliberate format. The alternative some customers ask for is the folded egg: cooked and folded by the supplier, flash-frozen and reheated on the grillGrillTo cook using direct radiant heat., with a fluffier, thicker texture and a consistency closer to an omelette. It is a different product rather than a simple swap, and the preference between the two comes down to taste.

How do you get a round, tender egg at home?

Invert the lid and screw ring of a mason jar in a skillet and crack the egg into it. Because the egg is not in direct contact with the pan base, it stays tender and white; adding a little water and covering the pan keeps it moist, and the egg cooks in around two minutes. A ring mould placed straight on the pan tends to brown the egg unevenly, which is exactly what the jar-lid method avoids.

References

Original video by Joshua Weissman Recipes . The Chef's Circle is the article publisher, not the video creator. This overview is written independently by The Chef's Circle editorial desk — watch the original on YouTube.

Keep reading

Related from the Community

The library is just the prep work

Step off the pass. Join the network.

A free account on The Chef's Circle app gets you a professional portfolio, a way in with chefs and kitchens across our 1.6 million-strong following, and a cut of the ad revenue on the content you make.