Joshua Weissman Recipes

The Best Chewy Brownies You'll Ever Eat

20 November 2026 · 5:17 watch

Advertisement

What makes a brownie chewy rather than cakey: eggs for structure, powdered sugar and water in the batter, gentle mixing and the right tin size.

Key takeaways

  • Chewiness comes from the batter itself rather than a special ingredient.
  • Without baking powder, eggs are what help the brownies rise.
  • Powdered sugar contains cornstarch, which thickens the batter.
  • Use an 8×8 tin; a 9×9 spreads the batter thin and overcooks it.

A chewy brownie sits between cakey and fudgy: it holds together when cut, with slight resistance rather than a crumb, and that chew comes from the batter itself rather than any special ingredient.

What builds the chew

Eggs carry the structure. In a batter without baking powder they are what help the brownies rise in the oven. A little water with the eggs gives the moist, gooey texture associated with boxed mixes, without their commercial emulsifiers. Powdered sugar helps too: it contains cornstarch, which thickens the batter. A one-bowl batter mixed by hand, with no electric mixer, can be every bit as chewy as a boxed brownie while tasting more of chocolate.

Mixing

Combine the dry and wet ingredients separately, then sprinkle the dry over the wet and fold until just combined; the batter will be thick.

Does tin size matter?

Yes. Bake this style in an 8×8 tin; a 9×9 spreads the batter thinner and the brownies overcook. That recipe bakes at 325°F (about 163°C), so check your oven's calibration before trusting the timing.

The shiny, crackly top

A thick, chewy, fudgy brownie can carry a glossy, crackly surface, and that shine comes from the batter rather than any single additive.

Storing

Fudgy brownies keep for three days at room temperature or up to five in the fridge.

References

Questions from the pass

Frequently asked questions

Why do some brownie recipes use powdered sugar?

Powdered sugar contains cornstarch, which thickens the batter and helps a homemade brownie reach the dense, chewy texture of a boxed mix without its chemical additives. It shapes texture rather than guaranteeing chew on its own, so balance it with the rest of the batter.

Do chewy brownies need baking powder?

No. In a batter without baking powder, the eggs provide the structure and help the brownies puff up in the oven. That makes egg size and how the eggs are mixed in more important than in a chemically leavened batter.

Does the size of the baking tin matter?

Yes. Bake this style in an 8×8 tin; a 9×9 spreads the batter thinner and the brownies overcook. If you change tin size, shorten or lengthen the bake and check doneness early.

Original video by Joshua Weissman Recipes . The Chef's Circle is the article publisher, not the video creator. This overview is written independently by The Chef's Circle editorial desk — watch the original on YouTube.

Keep reading

Related from the Community

The library is just the prep work

Step off the pass. Join the network.

A free account on The Chef's Circle app gets you a professional portfolio, a way in with chefs and kitchens across our 1.6 million-strong following, and a cut of the ad revenue on the content you make.